Services

CEO Succession Advisory.

CEO succession is too important to leave until it becomes urgent.

Choosing the next CEO is one of the most consequential decisions a board makes. The quality of that decision affects the company’s direction, the executive team, investor confidence and the continuity of the business.

Yet succession planning is often delayed, internal candidates are not properly tested, and boards discover too late that their preferred successor is not ready for the role.

Sterling Black advises boards and chairs on CEO succession, candidate assessment and readiness. We help establish what the business will need from its next CEO, evaluate potential successors against those requirements and provide independent evidence to support the board’s decision.

The objective is straightforward: a sound succession process, credible candidates and a board that is prepared to make the decision when the time comes.

Expert guidance for developing strong future leadership pipelines and smooth CEO transitions.

CEO succession planning is the board’s most important objective and the cornerstone of any business that lasts. But the stakes are high. The wrong choice can cost millions of dollars in lost revenue, lost momentum and lost reputation. And with tenures shortening, succession events are coming around faster and more often.

At Sterling Black, we use a data-driven process for identifying and developing ‘ready-now’ CEO candidates within your organisation. Whether you’re facing a sudden transition crisis or you want to futureproof leadership continuity, our team of succession experts can help. We’ll provide you with the data, the confidence and the decision support to select the right CEO for your company.

Four board decisions

The page is organised around the decisions a board has to make.

What will the next CEO need to deliver?

Define the experience, judgement, leadership capability and personal attributes required by the business over the next phase of its development. The right profile depends on the company’s strategy and circumstances, not a generic CEO competency model.

Who has the potential to succeed?

Assess internal candidates against the requirements of the role. Distinguish current performance from future CEO capability, identify gaps and establish how much development each candidate requires.

How ready are the candidates?

Test candidates’ judgement, commercial understanding, leadership effectiveness and ability to handle the demands of the role. Where necessary, develop candidates and review their progress against agreed requirements.

Can the board make a confident decision?

Give the board a clear view of candidate strengths, limitations, readiness and risks. Where appropriate, compare internal candidates with external options and establish a credible contingency plan for an unexpected transition.

A way in for boards

CEO Succession Readiness Review.

For chairs and boards that are not yet undertaking a full succession exercise. A review looks at:

  • Whether the organisation has credible internal CEO candidates.
  • Whether the board has agreed what the next CEO will need to achieve.
  • Whether candidates have been assessed against those requirements.
  • What development is needed before candidates are ready.
  • Whether there is a credible plan for an unexpected CEO departure.

It starts a substantive board advisory relationship without asking the board to commit immediately to a lengthy succession programme.

We can help you with:

  • Immediate assistance with unplanned CEO change
  • Short and long-term CEO succession planning
  • Objective benchmarking of internal & external candidates
  • CEO skills development programs for candidates

Why choose Sterling Black?

Top-tier international experience

We have 30+ years of experience with many international CEO succession assignments. Our best practice methodologies and approaches make us the gold standard in CEO assessment and development.

Experts in building CEO capability

We’re experts in CEO-level leadership. We have a deep understanding of the experience, skills and techniques that enable successful CEOs, and a tried-and-tested methodology for teaching them to potential successors.

Tailored solutions backed by data

Our sole focus is on helping you find the best CEO for your organisation. Whatever your situation, you can trust that we’ll provide best-practice advice and an unbiased, data-driven solution to fit your needs.

Our approach

  • Advice on the right CEO succession planning process for your organisation
  • Facilitation of a custom CEO assessment model
  • Development of high potential candidates
  • Development progress update
  • Facilitation of talent review with the board
  • Final selection methodology, including external candidates

GUIDE: Internal vs External CEO Succession

When your internal bench matches your best external options, how do you choose? Explore the commercial scenarios that favour insider vs outsider CEOs and use our interactive decision framework to assess your own context.

Learn more

Our clients

SiemensGEHoneywellIBMJ.P. MorganGoldman SachsCitibankJohnson & JohnsonHPKPMGGrant ThorntonRio TintoAshurst Perkins CoieWestpacTelstraQBEAustralian Government

Frequently Asked Questions

What is CEO succession?

CEO succession is the process of transitioning an organisation from the leadership of one Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to the next. It is a key component of corporate governance for boards.

What is CEO succession planning?

CEO succession planning is a board-driven activity where the organisation identifies, develops and ultimately decides on who the best internal options are to replace the current CEO once they leave.

How is succession planning done?

Success planning starts with the board defining the profile of their ideal CEO for the future. Potential CEO successors are then assessed and developed to be as close to the ideal CEO profile as they can be. The board will also search outside the company for external succession options, before choosing the right candidate from the shortlisted internal and external candidates.

Why is CEO succession important?

It takes two years of preparation for an executive to build the skills to competently take on the CEO role immediately upon promotion. If an executive is promoted without preparation, the organisation risks them derailing in the role and eroding significant value. Therefore, boards need to prepare internal CEO candidates for both unplanned short-term succession solutions and for building long-term capability and credible succession options.

Why do some boards fail to create succession plans?

The most common reasons are:

  • The board lacks maturity and understanding of the importance of CEO succession planning.
  • The board relies on naive or biased advice for the design of CEO succession planning, resulting in inadequate preparation.
  • The board is too busy and distracted to initiate effective CEO succession planning at the right time.

Is it better to hire internal or external CEOs?

Research shows that internal CEO candidates have significantly better outcomes in terms of performance and longevity in the role compared to external hires. Internal hires have longer average tenure (8.7 years vs 7.3 years) and are less likely to be terminated than their external counterparts (24% vs 30%). Additionally, promoting internally boosts employee morale and retention throughout the organisation, and has a positive effect on how staff view the company.

External hires are usually more expensive (+18–20% salary), require longer onboarding periods and have higher exit rates and lower performance evaluations in the first two years, in particular.

One exception where an external CEO candidate may be beneficial is when there is a need to make large changes to the organisation. Typically, this is easier to achieve with an outsider. However, in most other cases, an internal candidate is advantageous due to their existing relationships, inside knowledge of the company, and lower costs and time to onboard effectively.

What are the risks during CEO succession?

A number of risks can arise if the CEO succession process isn't managed well:

  • Without proper development of internal candidate options, boards can be left with a weak bench. This may force them to choose an external CEO successor, despite it being less effective in most circumstances.
  • Candidates may engage in competitive behaviour that leads to a breakdown in the organisation's function. This needs to be managed proactively through the process.
  • Not all leadership assessments are created equal. The wrong assessment method can provide information that isn't actually predictive of performance in the CEO role. This can distract the board from the factors that do matter and lead to poor decisions.
  • It can be challenging to retain internal candidates who are not successful, especially if the process isn't managed well.

Should CEOs be involved in planning their succession?

CEOs should not be involved in board planning or decision-making for CEO succession. If boards allow CEOs to contribute to the succession plan, they create the conditions for an insecure or incapable CEO to limit the opportunity for development, growth and exposure of potential candidates. The CEO may resort to survival politics and try to minimise the perceived threat of others to their position.

It is good practice, however, for CEOs to invest time in the development of the leadership skills of the CEO succession options. This is because they are much closer to the day-to-day interactions and performance of the candidates than the board.

For chairs and boards

A confidential conversation about succession.

If you are considering a succession decision or an assessment of your executive team, I would welcome a conversation.